Most people who struggle with “intrusive thoughts,” and most people who treat “intrusive thoughts,” think that these thoughts are involuntary and uncontrollable. Thus the term “intrusive.”
The truth is that the vast majority of what people call “intrusive thoughts” are actually being thought or imagined on purpose, in an effort to figure something out and thus prevent something terrible from happening.
Here’s an example of what this might look like:
A person sees a knife near someone they love, and it occurs to them that they could stab that person with the knife. This terrifies them: What if they really did stab them?
So what do they do? They start trying to figure out if they would actually do it. They purposely imagine stabbing their loved one, in order to gauge their emotional response to that idea. And when they aren’t 100% sure what their response was, they imagine it again. Or they might imagine doing it another way, or start thinking about other violent ideas, to gauge their response to those ideas. They get stuck between reassuring themselves that they would never do it, and convincing themselves that they could do it, in order to stay vigilant.
This person thus repeatedly imagines stabbing someone, not realizing that they’re doing so on purpose for the reasons described above. This person will say that they are experiencing intrusive thoughts all day. They won’t realize that the majority of these intrusive thoughts are actually being thought on purpose, to try and figure something out.
The above is a zoomed-in example of what this might look like in a specific moment, in response to a specific trigger. If we zoom out, people with “intrusive thoughts” are typically spending all day every day trying to figure something out, whether or not there is a specific trigger. For example, someone with OCD about whether they are a pedophile is likely to wake up in the morning with a pit in their stomach and immediately launch into trying to figure out if they really are one (e.g., by analyzing their thoughts and feelings, conducting thought experiments, reviewing past experiences, doing research on the internet, etc.). This person might say that they are having “intrusive thoughts” about being a pedophile all day, but in fact they are spending all day actively trying to figure out if they are one. In other words, these thoughts aren’t being done to this person; they are something that this person is doing.
On purpose?
Admittedly, it’s tricky to say that this person is doing this thinking “on purpose.” As with any compulsion, the person experiences themselves as not having a choice, because they are terrified of what might happen if they don’t do it. Saying that they are thinking these thoughts “on purpose” isn’t intended to minimize that subjective experience or to blame the patient. Rather it is meant to restore the patient’s agency, by showing them that what is happening is subject to their control, and that despite how terrified they are, they can make the decision to stop doing it. In other words, no one is saying that the person wants to be ruminating all the time, just as no one is saying that someone wants to compulsively wash their hands all the time. The difference is that when it comes to handwashing, everyone knows that the person is the one doing the washing, but when it comes to thinking, people get confused about the fact that the patient is doing it. (Of course it’s also harder to wash your hands without realizing you’re doing it.)
You can’t have it both ways
Another problem with the term “intrusive thoughts” is that this language allows you to imagine that you can somehow combat the “intrusive thoughts,” while continuing to try and figure it out. Once you realize that the thoughts aren’t intrusive (happening to you) and are just rumination (something you are doing), you realize that these are all the same thought process, and that you can’t have your cake and eat it too. In short, the “intrusive thoughts” are just you trying to figure it out, so you can’t keep trying to figure it out and also make those thoughts go away.
If you want to stop thinking about it all the time, you will have to stop trying to figure it out. These are mutually exclusive options.
(This can be a very hard choice to make, since the person thinks that trying to figure it out is potentially preventing something terrible from happening. Therefore, once a person realizes that they will have to make that choice between trying to figure it out and feeling better, they may need to address their justifications for ruminating.)
But isn’t there an initial intrusive thought?
The answer to this question is yes, but it is liminal, and the entire thought process that follows is compulsive rumination.
To explain this, I think it’s helpful to imagine how Pure O might be depicted in film.
Here’s how you might expect it to be depicted (which is incorrect):
We see a man standing in the kitchen with his wife, and noticing a knife on the counter. Next we see his obsession: him picking up the knife and stabbing his wife. Then we return to the present moment where we see the man panicked and deeply engaged in thought.
But that isn’t what Pure O actually looks like. That part about the obsession doesn’t happen. The accurate way to depict it would be as follows:
We see the man standing in the kitchen with his wife, and noticing a knife on the counter. He is immediately panicked and deeply engaged in thought.
Yes, he had a terrifying thought/feeling that he could stab his wife, but that thought is liminal; it doesn’t really take up any time or space. There’s no discrete period of obsession before the person starts ruminating, and his entire thought process is rumination. Again, this is important because people sometimes think that part of their thought process is the obsession and should be given room to breathe while they try to eliminate the rest of the thought process. This leads to a very confused attempt to stop ruminating that doesn’t make sense and doesn’t work.
Shifting our language
In light of the above, I prefer not to use the term “intrusive thoughts” at all, because it misrepresents what is happening in a way that fails to differentiate between obsession and compulsion, and thus colludes with the lack of control a person already feels about their thinking.